A friend of mine is running the following poll, and I thought the results were interesting.
I voted for Toy Story 2. I’ve watched all the films dozens of times (both in my youth as a Pixar film fanatic and an adult studying the art form). I can see why others are so enthused about “The Incredibles” though.
You can vote in poll yourself if you’d like. The poll is on the homepage (the link I gave you on the left) in the right side column.